Paper Arena

Compare research contributions, evidence and reusable work on a six-tier rubric. Scores come from an independent review.

Review snapshot Scoring rubric v1.0.0 ·

Papers by tier

Reviewed 21
  1. 0 T1
  2. 10 T2
  3. 7 T3
  4. 3 T4
  5. 1 T5
  6. 0 T6

Paper leaderboard

Reviewed 21·Awaiting a rating 1

Ranks and ties follow the review record. TBD marks a title awaiting a match to the site and may include work under review or awaiting submission. Papers marked “under view” are in scope and await an arena rating.

Paper leaderboard
RankPaperScoreTierWork date
1 TBD 8.5 Tier 2 Date pending
2 TBD 8.5 Tier 2 Date pending
3 TBD 8.5 Tier 2 Date pending
4 TBD 8.5 Tier 2 Date pending
5 TBD 8.0 Tier 2 Date pending
6 When Is Program Structure Required? Certificate-Grounded Calibration of Program-Induction Difficulty arXiv 2026 8.0 Tier 2 Preprint posted
7 Complex Utility, Simple Calibration: Decision Sufficiency in RAG Evidence Selection WSDM 2027 8.0 Tier 2 Accepted
8 TBD 8.0 Tier 2 Date pending
9 TBD 8.0 Tier 2 Date pending
10 TBD 8.0 Tier 2 Date pending
11 TBD 7.5 Tier 3 Date pending
12 TBD 7.5 Tier 3 Date pending
13 TBD 7.5 Tier 3 Date pending
14 TBD 7.5 Tier 3 Date pending
15 TBD 7.5 Tier 3 Date pending
16 TBD 7.0 Tier 3 Date pending
17 TBD 7.0 Tier 3 Date pending
18 PAIRSAFE: Proxy-Resistant Paired Safety Evaluation for Refusal Boundaries AACL-IJCNLP 2026 6.5 Tier 4 Accepted
19 Contract-Governed Training for Earth Observation: Observed Service Agreement Graphs and Coverage-Accuracy Trade-offs IGARSS 2026 6.0 Tier 4 Accepted
20 Optimistic Feasible Search for Closed-Loop Fair Threshold Decision-Making WCCI (IJCNN) 2026 5.5 Tier 4 Accepted
21 When +1% Is Not Enough: A Paired Bootstrap Protocol for Evaluating Small Improvements PAKDD 2026 Qualitative Tier 5 Accepted
— ARC-CTRL: Audit-Guided Closed-Loop Trust Control for Surrogate-Assisted Evolutionary Hyperparameter Optimization WCCI (CEC) 2026 under view — Accepted

Date order uses the date shown for each paper. Entries with a pending date appear last.

Scoring rubricv1.0.0 ·
TierScoreInterpretation
Tier 19–10The work offers an important new insight or gives researchers a capability they previously lacked. Strong evidence covers the key conditions under which the central claim holds. The contribution is substantial enough to change how researchers understand or approach the problem.
Tier 28–8.5The work makes a clear and important advance over prior research. Ample evidence supports the central conclusion, and the paper gives convincing answers to the main questions that could change it.
Tier 37–7.5The work solves a well-defined research problem and makes a complete contribution worth sharing. The available evidence supports the conclusions under the stated conditions, and the limits of their applicability are clear.
Tier 45–6.5The work makes an identifiable contribution, but gaps remain in key comparisons, validation or reasoning. These gaps affect readers’ ability to judge whether the main conclusions hold or under what conditions they generalize.
Tier 5QualitativeThe main value lies in reusable data, code, experimental records or practical experience. The material is suitable for a technical report or an open resource that other researchers can consult and use.
Tier 6QualitativeA clear independent contribution has yet to emerge, and the material offers limited results that others can reuse. It is suitable for archiving as a record of the research process.

Copy text

Copy was unavailable. Select and copy the text below.